What is Fair in Love and War

Madison Marshall, Law Clerk • November 22, 2024

In New York, marriage is seen as more than just a societal standard of a public declaration of love and commitment, but also an economic investment and partnership between the two spouses. A divorce in New York initiates once one spouse brings a lawsuit against the other. While these matters can be resolved in different ways, in many divorces, the division of assets and finances play a significant role in divorce proceedings. With the majority of married couples not having a pre-nuptial agreement prior to getting married, which spells out how assets will be divided if a divorce occurs, an understanding of the process is important.


The divorce process includes the division of assets, called Equitable Distribution, which as a central principle is the ideas of equality and fairness when deciding who is entitled to what property. The goal of Equitable Distribution is to divide Marital Property fairly between the divorcing spouses, with an emphasis on equal monetary value to each divorced spouse, unless a prenuptial agreement says otherwise. There are exceptions in these matters when there are items purchased prior to the marriage or personal gifts or judgments from others outside of the relationship that are awarded during the marriage that are considered separate property and not subject to the principles of equitable distribution.


Under the state’s laws governing Equitable Distribution, property is divided into marital property and separate property. Marital property is typically anything that either spouse purchased or received during the marriage and prior to the execution of a separation or prenuptial agreement, even items that are titled to only one spouse. Retirement or pensions plans can be considered marital property for the purposes of equitable distribution. However, there are exceptions to these general propositions and reputable presumptions.


The Court has significant discretion is determining what is “fair” at times of dividing assets. Factors the Court considers when making these decisions are each spouse’s income, the length of the marriage, each spouse’s age and health, any maintenance awards, if the custodial parent needs to live in or own the marital home, the loss of health benefits from divorce, if there are claims of domestic violence, if there is a companion animal, and any other factor the court seems proper to consider. N.Y. DOM. REL. §236(5)(d)(1)-(16). The Court is to analyze each case based on its own unique facts and consider the lives effected by its decision.


Contact our attorneys at Flink Maswick Law PLLC that handle divorces to speak with us further on how this stage of divorce works.


The foregoing is not to be considered as legal advice and each case contains unique factors which should be considered by your attorney of choice. 

By Flink Maswick Law PLLC November 12, 2025
James L. Maswick, a partner with Flink Maswick Law PLLC, was asked to contribute his thoughts to a real estate blog post from a Lake Placid-based real estate agency, Merrill L. Thomas, Inc. You can access the blog post, which is entitled “Smoke Detectors in Real Estate Transactions” and is written by realtor Jonathan Gorgas, via this link: https://www.adirondackestates.com/about/real-estate-blog/smoke-detectors-in-real-estate- transactions/ Jamey thanks Jonathan and the folks at Merrill L. Thomas for asking him to contribute to this effort, especially on such an important topic.  If you would like attorneys from our office to either speak to your group or contribute in writing for matters such as a blog post, article, comment, quote, or the like, please do not hesitate to reach out to our firm.
American flag with the words
By Flink Maswick Law November 7, 2025
Our offices will be closed on Tuesday, November 11, 2025 in observance of Veterans Day. We will reopen Wednesday, November 12 at 8:30 a.m.  Thank you to all veterans for your service and sacrifice!
Attorney and Partner Ed Fink and Associate Attorney Elliot J. Vanier of Flink Maswick Law PLLC.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC October 24, 2025
Edward B. Flink, Attorney and Partner, of Flink Maswick Law in Lake Placid NY, named Super Lawyer for 15th straight year.
Flink Maswick Law Logo
By Flink Maswick Law October 10, 2025
Our office will be closed on Monday, October 13, 2025, in observance of the federal holiday. We will resume normal business hours on Tuesday, October 14 at 8:30 am. Thank you for your understanding and continued support.
Group of people atop a mountain summit, posing by a sign that reads
By Flink Maswick Law August 28, 2025
Happy Labor Day from all of us at Flink Maswick Law.
Person riding a red Harley-Davidson motorcycle on a road; wearing a helmet, jacket, and light blue pants.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC August 22, 2025
Some of us in the office are out today attending the final services of Favor R. Smith, a well-known attorney and longtime Lake Placid resident who passed away in late July of this year. Favor’s son, Favor J. Smith, also an attorney, worked with Flink Maswick Law PLLC for a number of years. Below please find the thoughts and reflections of Ed Flink about Favor R. Smith. From all of us at Flink Maswick Law to Favor’s family, we are thinking of you during this difficult time. Thank you, Jamey Maswick
By Flink Maswick Law July 22, 2025
Please note that our office in Tupper Lake will be closed due to construction renovation work from Monday, July 28, 2025 through Friday, August 1, 2025. During this time, our team will be available for in-person visits, calls, or email responses while they work from our Lake Placid office. We encourage you to plan accordingly and reach out if you have any questions. Our Tupper Lake office will resume normal operations again on Monday, August 4, 2025 at 8:30 a.m.  Thank you for your understanding and continued support. We hope you’re enjoying a safe and relaxing summer!
By Flink Maswick Law July 21, 2025
Attorney and partner Molly S. Hann of Flink Maswick Law PLLC was invited to speak to the Adirondack Champlain Valley Realtor group on July 17, 2025 at the Malone Golf Club. She spoke at the annual ACV realtor member meeting luncheon and discussed the topics of scams, fraud, and land scams. Molly spoke to a crowd of some 15 realtors that were present and took questions after.  If you would like Molly or another attorney associated with Flink Maswick Law PLLC to speak to your group, please do not hesitate to contact us regarding availability.
By Madison J. Marshall, Law Clerk July 17, 2025
Note from James L. Maswick – I asked our Law Clerk, Madison J. Marshall, to write a brief series on statutes of limitation in actions which involve personal injury. Madison’s series will explore how they can differ by cause of action, by defendant, and by the tort that is alleged. This is part 1 – we hope you enjoy reading! As always, for your specific situation, consult an attorney as soon as possible, as this series is for general information only.
By Flink Maswick Law July 3, 2025
Our offices will be closed on Friday, July 4th in observance of Independence Day. Happy Birthday America! We will reopen on Monday, July 7th at 8:30 AM .  We hope you have a safe and joyful 4th of July celebration with your friends and family!
Show More